Team logo
Team group photo

RESULT

RESULT

Round 1-Random Mutation

1.Screening of mutant strains

Firstly, the atmospheric and room-temperature plasma mutation system (ARTP) was set out to screen mutants with higher CLPs yield. After ARTP treatment, we obtained 200 mutant strains. The anti-microbial activity of these strains was assessed by oxford cup method. We determined the size of the inhibition zone of these mutant strains against the plant pathogen Xanthomonas spp. QKHT-5 to characterize the strength of their inhibitory activity. After multiple rounds of screening, we obtained a series of mutant strains with stronger antibacterial activity than HMBY. Among them, the mutant strain HMBY-106 achieved the largest antibacterial diameter. As shown in Figure1, the inhibitory diameter of HMBY and HMBY-106 is (12±1) mm and (16±1) mm respectively, which suggest a significantly stronger antibacterial activity of HMBY-106 than HMBY.

Figure 1. Screening of HMBY mutant by oxford cup method. The marker “0” represents the extract from the wild-type HMBY strain, and the other numbers (for example, 73, 89, and 106) represent the extracts from different mutant strains. The strains were grown in soybean meal medium, and their lipopeptides were extracted and added to the cells created with Oxford cups on the solid medium containing Xanthomonas spp. QKHT-5. 0-LB represents the extract from the wild-type HMBY strain grown in LB liquid medium. Larger inhibition diameter indicates higher concentrations of anti-bacterial components in the extracts.

We further validate the antibacterial activity of HMBY-106 by the method of minimum inhibition concentration. The minimum inhibitory dilution of HMBY and HMBY-106 is 25 and 26 respectively (Figure 2), which suggest a stronger antibacterial activity of HMBY-106.

Figure 2. Validation of the anti-pathogenic potential of HMBY-106 by the method of minimum inhibition concentration. Inhibition of the growth of Xanthomonas spp. QKHT-5 by the extracts from HMBY and HMBY-106. The extract from HMBY was diluted in 2-fold series and repeated in rows A-C. The extract from HMBY-106 was diluted in 2-fold series and repeated in rows D-F. Blank LB medium was used as a positive control in row G, and LB medium containing 1% Xanthomonas spp. QKHT-5 was used as a negative control in row H. The first five wells in rows A-C and the first six wells in rows D-F are transparent and translucent. (c) Inhibitory effect of wild-type and mutant Bacillus against Xanthomonas spp. QKHT-5. The anti-bacterial diameter of HMBY was 12 ± 1 mm, and the anti-bacterial diameter of HMBY-106 was 16 ± 1 mm; the minimum inhibitory dilution was 2n times that of the lipopeptide sample without inhibition. HMBY has no inhibitory effect after 25 times dilution, and HMBY-106 has no inhibitory effect after 26 times dilution.

2.Analysis of CLPs

To explore the anti-microbial metabolites, we searched for the secondary metabolite biosynthetic gene clusters across the genome. A complete set of NRPS modules for synthesizing iturin, surfactin, and fengycin (Figure 1b) was found in the genome of HMBY. In addition, the structure of CLPs was determined by LC-MS using the fermentation product of HMBY. Thirteen CLPs were revealed, comprising three iturin, five fengycin and five surfactin (Table 1).

Figure 3. Characterization of the nonribosomal peptide synthetases (NRPSs) synthetic modules of iturin, surfactin, and fengycin in the genome of HMBY. The InterPro database was used to analyze the protein sequence matching the lipopeptide synthetic genes.
Table 1. CLPs of HMBY detected by mass spectrometry.
Peak number Liopeptide name [M+H]+ [M+Na]+
a C14 Iturin A 1043.55225 1065.53186
b C15 Iturin A 1057.56836 1079.54834
c C16 Iturin A 1071.58704 1093.56421
d C14 fengycinA 1435.77332 1457.75183
e C15 fengycinA 1449.78821 1471.76514
f C16 fengycinA 1463.80481 1485.77991
g C17 fengycinA 1477.82202 1499.79565
h C17 fengycinB 1505.85583 1527.83081
i C13 surfactinA 1008.65845 1030.63818
j C14 surfactinA 1022.67584 1044.65356
k C15 surfactinA 1036.68909 1058.66882
l C15 surfactinB 1022.67322 1044.65491
m C15 surfactinC 1036.69055 1058.67090

To investigate if HMBY-106 synthesizes more lipopeptides than HMBY, we quantified the amount of the CLPs in HMBY and HMBY-106. HPLC detection of the fermentation product revealed the production of iturin, fengycin and surfactin by B. velezensis HBMY. In addition, HMBY-106 had around 2 times higher CLPs production compared to HMBY.

Figure 4. (a and b) HPLC analysis of iturin, surfactin, and fengycin produced by HMBY and HMBY-106. (c) Quantification of the CLPs produced in HMBY and HMBY-106

3.Determination of lipopeptide gene expression

To determine the regulation of CLPs biosynthesis genes expression in high-yield CLPs-producing mutant, qPCR was performed to assess the CLPs genes expression of HMBY and HMBY-106 (Figure 5). The results showed that the transcription levels of the NRPS genes for iturin A-D, surfactin AA-AD, and fengycin A-E in HMBY-106 are all higher than their levels in HMBY.

Figure 5. Real-time quantitative reverse transcription PCR analysis of lipopeptide NRPS genes in HMBY and HMBY-106. The mRNAs were extracted from the cells at the plateau stage (24 h). The primers of the NRPS genes are shown in Part section.

4.Cell growth viability analyses

Further biomass and cell growth viability analyses revealed the gene mutations on strain performance. We compared the growth curves of HMBY and mutants to assess the effect of gene mutations on bacterial growth (Figure 6). After their growth reached the plateau (stationary phase), the cell densities decreased quickly. HMBY and HMBY-106 exhibited similar growth rate, but the HMBY-106 declined more quickly after the plateau than HMBY. This indicate that the higher yield of CLPs result from HMBY-106 was not result of the bacterial density.

Figure 6. Changes in cell growth of the HMBY and HMBY-106 strains.

Round2-Targeted gene engineering – uncovering regulatory genes

1.Comparative genomics analysis of HMBY and HMBY-106

To investigate the specific genes that are responsible for the higher-yield CLPs of HMBY-106 than the wild-type strain, we sequenced and analyzed the whole genomes of HMBY and HMBY-106. Three genes (cdaA, relA and cheB) were found to acquire missense mutations in their protein-coding regions (Figure 1).

Figure 7. Gene mutations on the increased production of CLPs in HMBY-106. (a) The domains of CdaA, CheB, and RelA. The mutated sites are indicated with lines above the corresponding domains.

2.Targeted gene mutation of HMBY and CLPs yield

To deterimine whether all these gene mutations regulate CLPs synthesis, the CRISPR-Cas9 system gene editing vector pJOE8999 was employed to constructed the targeted mutant strains. The genes cdaA, rel and cheB in HBMY were respectively substituted by the mutant genes from HBMY-106. As shown in Figure 2, the amount of CLPs produced by the mutants of Rel and CdaA were higher than that of wide-type strain HMBY. CLPs yield of engineered Rel and CdaA mutant strain was increased compared to the wild-type strain. The mutation of CheB dramaticaly decrease CLPs production of HMBY. More importantly, we obtained the strain HMBY-rel, which is more productive than HMBY-106.

Figure 8. Comparative CLPs production in wide-type, random and targeted mutant strains cultivated in fermentation medium for about 48 hours.

3.Cell growth viability analyses

In addition, the cell growth of the mutant strains and HMBY were assessed. The strains HMBY, HMBY-106 and HMBY-cheB exhibited similar growth rate, but the HMBY-106 and HMBY-cheB declined more quickly after the plateau than HMBY. The mutant strain HMBY-rel and HMBY-cdaA exihibited a lower growth rate than HMBY. This indicate that the higher yield of CLPs result from HMBY-rel and HMBY-cdaA was not due to the bacterial density.

Figure 9. Changes in cell growth of the wide-type, random and targeted mutant strains.

4.Analysis of antibacterial activity

The anti-microbial activity of these strains was assessed by oxford cup method. We determined the size of the inhibition zone of these mutant strains against the plant pathogen Xanthomonas spp. QKHT-5 to characterize the strength of their inhibitory activity. After multiple rounds of screening, we obtained a series of mutant strains with stronger antibacterial activity than HMBY. Among them, the mutant strain HMBY-relA achieved the largest antibacterial diameter. As shown in Figure 4, the inhibitory diameter of HMBY-106 and HMBY-relA is (16.6±2.1) mm and (21.6±0.3) mm respectively, which suggest a significantly stronger antibacterial activity of HMBY-relA than HMBY-106.

Figure 10. Screening of HMBY mutant by oxford cup method. The marker “WT” represents the extract from the wild-type HMBY strain, and the other numbers (for example,cdaA, relA, cheB, and 106) represent the extracts from different mutant strains. The strains were grown in soybean meal medium, and their lipopeptides were extracted and added to the cells created with Oxford cups on the solid medium containing Xanthomonas spp. QKHT-5. 0-LB represents the extract from the wild-type HMBY strain grown in LB liquid medium. Larger inhibition diameter indicate higher concentrations of anti-bacterial components in the extracts.

5.Determination of lipopeptide gene expression

To determine the regulation of CLPs biosynthesis genes expression in high-yield CLPs-producing mutant, qPCR was performed to assess the CLPs genes expression of HMBY,HMBY-106,HMBY-relA, HMBY-CdaA and HMBY-CheB (Figure 5). The results showed that the transcription levels of the NRPS genes for iturin, surfactin , and fengycin in HMBY-relA are all higher than their levels in HMBY-106.

Figure 11. Real-time quantitative reverse transcription PCR analysis of lipopeptide NRPS genes in HMBY, HMBY-106,HMBY-relA, HMBY-CdaA and HMBY-CheB. The mRNAs were extracted from the cells at the plateau stage (24 h).

6.A regulatory model of CLPs biosynthesis

We proposed a new regulatory model that the mutations of relA and cdaA regulate the CLPs production. Rel synthesizes (p)ppGpp, a component that reduces cellular GTP levels, and upregulates amino acid biosynthesis. The mutation of rel may up-regulate the amount of amino acids. Alternatively, the NRPS genes may be up-regulated by the mutations of rel or cdaA. The increase supply of substrate amino acids and the up-regulated NRPS genes expression improve the CLPs biosynthesis.

Figure 12. A regulatory model that rel and cdaA mutations regulate CLPs biosynthesis was proposed.

Round 3-Metabolic Engineering

1. Construction of dual-gRNA and single-gRNA CRISPR-Cas systems for competing pathway knockout

To redirect the CLPs biosynthesis flux exclusively towards fengycin biosynthesis, we aimed to knockout the long gene clusters fragment responsible for the synthesis of competing lipopeptides surfactin (srfA-D) and iturin (ituA-D). Based on the pJOE8999 plasmid, we constructed a dual-gRNA CRISPR-Cas system, designated as pWLS. This vector was designed to express two guide RNAs simultaneously, targeting two specific sites, significantly improving the editing efficiency for long fragment. Additionally, a single-gRNA knockout vector, pJOE8999-ΔsrfB, was also constructed for comparative analysis.

Figure 13. Schematic of the dual-gRNA empty vector pWLS used for targeted knockout of srf and itu gene clusters,and the dual gRNA casette.

The recombinant plasmids, pWLS-Δsrf, pWLS-Δitu, and pJOE8999-Δsrf, were successfully constructed via a one-step multi-fragment assembly strategy. Each plasmid contained the corresponding gRNA expression cassettes and the respective upstream and downstream homology arms (each approximately 1500bp) for the targeted gene cluster, serving as templates for homologous recombination after Cas9-induced double-strand breaks.

2. Transformation, Comparative Efficiency Analysis, and Mutant Verification

The constructed editing vectors (pWLS-Δsrf, pWLS-Δitu, and pJOE8999-ΔsrfB) were electroporated into the high-yielding strain HMBY-rel. Transformants were selected on LB agar supplemented with 5 µg/mL kanamycin and 0.2% D-mannose (to induce Cas9 expression) after incubation at 30°C for 2 days.

A comparative analysis revealed significant differences in performance between the single- and dual-gRNA systems. Following D-mannose induction, the viability of B. velezensis transformants carrying the single-gRNA vector was markedly lower than those with the dual-gRNA system, as clearly observed on solid medium plates.

Figure 14.Screening of transformants for recombinant plasmids in host strain HMBY-rel. (a and b) D-mannose–induced transformants of B. velezensis carrying the single-gRNA vector; (c and d) D-mannose–induced transformants carrying the dual-gRNA vector.

Colony PCR verification further demonstrated the superior efficiency and accuracy of the dual-gRNA system. While the single-gRNA transformants showed messy, incorrect, or absent bands, the dual-gRNA system produced clear, correctly sized bands corresponding to the expected deletions.The editing vectors pWLS-Δsrf and pWLS-Δitu were sequentially introduced into HMBY-rel. Mutants from each transformation round were selected and screened via colony PCR. DNA sequencing confirmed the successful knockout of both the srf and itu gene clusters, yielding the final engineered strain HMBY-rel-ΔsrfΔitu. This result validates the high efficiency of our dual-gRNA system for long genomic fragment knockout.

Figure 15. Colony PCR verification of the HMBY-rel-ΔsrfΔitu mutant. Lanes 2-5: verification of the srf cluster deletion; Lanes 6-9: verification of the itu cluster deletion. The size of the PCR products matches the expected fragments after successful knockout. The results were further validated by sequencing.(e)Lanes 1-2: PCR products from B. velezensis transformants. The presence of messy, incorrect, or absent bands demonstrates the low editing efficiency and accuracy of the single-gRNA CRISPR-Cas9 system. M: DNA molecular weight marker.(f)

3. Plasmid Curing and Ongoing Functional Analyses

For plasmid curing, transformants were replica-picked onto antibiotic-free LB plates, incubated overnight at 50°C to promote plasmid loss, and then streaked at 42°C to isolate single colonies. Successful plasmid curing was confirmed by the absence of growth on kanamycin-containing plates alongside normal growth on antibiotic-free LB plates.

Figure 16.Plasmid curing confirmed by growth only on antibiotic-free LB after high-temperature treatment.

Subsequent phenotypic and functional analyses are currently underway, including HPLC-MS/MS for lipopeptide quantification, gene expression profiling, growth curve monitoring, and antibacterial activity assays. These studies aim to comprehensively evaluate the effects of the srf and itu knockouts on fengycin production and overall strain performance.

Round 4-NRPS communication (COM) domain reprogramming

Our software platform offers a comprehensive computational solution for reprogramming NRPS communication (COM) domain. It integrates multiple bioinformatic tools—including MAFFT for sequence alignment, IQ-TREE for phylogenetic analysis, and InterProScan for domain annotation—into a unified and automated workflow. Key functionalities include fen sequence integration, functional domain mapping, and automated extraction of COM junction regions. Through multi-dimensional data analysis, the platform successfully identified four critical residue sites, providing precise targets for experimental validation. The predicted fen COM reprogramming will further be validated by our wet-lab results.

Designed to serve the iGEM community, this software provides a rational design pipeline from gene sequences to functional predictions. By incorporating structural modeling and machine learning strategies, it supports the reprogramming of NRPS machinery, helping teams efficiently develop high-performance microbial strains and strengthening the computational foundation of synthetic biology projects.

Figure 17. Sequence alignment of fengycin NRPS COM domain pairs, analyzed using our developed software to guide domain-swapping engineering.

Conclusion

This study established a complete technical chain for cyclic lipopeptide (CLPs) optimization through four progressive rounds of experiments. We not only obtained the high-yield mutant strain HMBY-106 and the relA targeted mutant strain with superior performance at the phenotypic screening level, but also elucidated the roles of relA, cdaA, and cheB in CLPs synthesis at the molecular mechanism level, and proposed a regulatory model. In addition, at the metabolic optimization level, we constructed a dual-gRNA system for knocking out competing pathways, and developed an automated software to provide computational support for rational engineering. The research findings offer a reusable technical route for the optimization of microbial secondary metabolites, aligning with the needs of sustainable agriculture (SDG 2) and the development of environmentally friendly chemicals (SDG 12).

Back to top