Our DBTL Cycles
Critical Environmental Problem: Per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) contamination represents one of the most pervasive environmental health crises of our time, with over 200 million Americans exposed to contaminated drinking water. PFOA (perfluorooctanoic acid), a particularly toxic PFAS compound, persists indefinitely in the environment and bioaccumulates in human tissue, causing liver damage, decreased fertility, and increased cancer risk.
Innovation Gap: Current detection methods require expensive laboratory equipment, lengthy processing times (days to weeks), and specialized expertise, making them unsuitable for real-time environmental monitoring or point-of-use applications.
Our Solution: Engineer a rapid, cost-effective biosensor platform using synthetic biology principles to enable real-time PFOA detection at environmentally relevant concentrations (low micromolar range) with field-deployable simplicity.
Phase 1 - Foundation Validation: Systematically test and validate/reject 2024 genetic circuit designs using optimized experimental conditions based on iGEM Jamboree judge feedback. This critical decision point prevented months of unproductive optimization.
Phase 2 - Computational Discovery: Deploy multi-database reverse screening algorithms to identify superior PFOA-binding proteins, replacing literature-based selection with data-driven target discovery across 2,800+ protein candidates.
Phase 3 - Protein Engineering: Establish scalable production and purification pipelines for TYMS-GFP fusion proteins, including structural validation through analytical ultracentrifugation and circular dichroism spectroscopy.
Phase 4 - Quantitative Characterization: Determine binding kinetics and thermodynamics using multiple orthogonal techniques (MST, DSF, UV-Vis) to establish biosensor design parameters.
Phase 5 - Transcriptomics Innovation: Engineer RNA-seq workflows to discover PFOA-responsive bacterial promoters for next-generation genetic circuit development.
Binding Affinity Achievement: Successfully determined Kd = 217 µM for TYMS-PFOA interaction through rigorous MST analysis, representing a 10-fold improvement over previous hL-FAB-based approaches and meeting our target sensitivity for environmental detection.
Protein Production Excellence: Achieved >95% pure TYMS-GFP fusion protein through optimized two-step purification (His-tag + size exclusion chromatography), with correct molecular weight (64 kDa) and maintained fluorescence activity.
RNA Quality Standards: Developed and validated RNA extraction protocols achieving A260/230 ratios >1.5 for 67% of samples (16/24), enabling high-quality RNA-seq library preparation for transcriptomics analysis.
Educational Impact: Reached 200+ students across 5 educational institutions through systematic curriculum development and hands-on workshops, establishing a scalable model for synthetic biology education.
Technical Innovations: Generated 3 novel methodological improvements: corrected PFOA computational structure, optimized bacterial RNA extraction protocols, and developed restriction enzyme troubleshooting guidelines.
Systematic Design → Build → Test → Learn Methodology: Applied rigorous engineering principles across 5 major engineering cycles with 15+ documented iterations, ensuring every decision was supported by quantitative data and failed approaches were thoroughly analyzed for learning opportunities.
Evidence-Based Decision Making: Implemented statistical analysis and quantitative metrics for all major project pivots, including the critical decision to abandon genetic circuits (p > 0.05 significance test) and pursue protein-based approaches (ΔTm = -3.2°C validation).
Risk Mitigation Strategy: Maintained parallel experimental approaches and validation techniques to ensure project continuity, exemplified by our multi-technique binding validation (MST, DSF, UV-Vis) and computational screening verification protocols.
Scalability Focus: Developed reproducible protocols suitable for technology transfer, including detailed troubleshooting guides and optimization parameters for future team implementation.
Critical Engineering Decision Point: Our project inherited genetic circuit designs from the 2024 iGEM cycle that had shown inconsistent performance during initial testing. Rather than assume these circuits were fundamentally flawed, we implemented a systematic validation approach to determine whether previous failures were due to suboptimal experimental conditions or inherent design limitations.
Hypothesis-Driven Approach: Based on detailed feedback from 2024 iGEM Jamboree judges, we hypothesized that apparent circuit failures resulted from: (1) inappropriate host strain selection (DH5α vs. BL21(DE3)), (2) interference from yellow-colored LB media with GFP fluorescence detection (λmax = 509 nm), and (3) insufficient incubation time for protein expression.
Success Criteria & Decision Framework: We established quantitative success criteria requiring ≥2-fold fluorescence increase at 250 µM PFOA exposure with statistical significance (p < 0.05). This threshold was based on typical biosensor sensitivity requirements and our target environmental detection range.
Strategic Importance: This cycle represented a critical go/no-go decision point that would determine our entire project trajectory. Success would lead to genetic circuit optimization, while failure would necessitate a complete pivoted approach to protein-based biosensors, potentially costing 6+ months of development time.
Host Strain Optimization:
Media Engineering for Optical Clarity:
Comprehensive Control Strategy:
Experimental Setup:
PFOA Treatment:
Measurement Protocol:
Results:
Conclusion:
Decision:
Impact: Saved 6+ months of optimization effort
Design:
Build:
Test Results:
Learn:
Design Improvements:
Build Protocol:
Test Results:
Learn & Future Optimization:
Fundamental Challenge: Previous iGEM teams relied on literature-based protein selection, leading to suboptimal candidates like hL-FAB (human liver fatty acid-binding protein) that exhibited poor expression yields (<10 mg/L) and insufficient binding affinity for environmental applications.
Innovation Opportunity: Replace anecdotal protein selection with systematic computational screening across multiple databases, enabling unbiased discovery of superior PFOA-binding proteins based on quantitative binding predictions and druggability scores.
Quantitative Success Criteria: Identify protein candidates meeting four critical requirements: • Predicted binding affinity >2-fold higher than hL-FAB (target: <-8.0 kcal/mol) • Cross-database validation across ≥3 independent platforms for statistical robustness • Production cost feasibility (<$500 per mg for laboratory-scale studies) • Experimental validation showing thermal stability changes ≥2°C upon ligand binding
Strategic Impact: This systematic approach replaced the fundamental biosensor recognition element through data-driven discovery, potentially identifying novel protein-PFOA interactions absent from existing literature and establishing a replicable methodology for future PFAS detection targets.
Comprehensive Database Strategy:
Quantitative Filtering Rubric:
Data Integration Pipeline:
Search Execution:
Analysis Pipeline:
Filtering Results:
Top Candidates:
Key Insights:
Efficiency Gained:
DSF Principle:
Experimental Design:
Sample Preparation:
Instrument Setup:
Thermal Shift Results:
Unexpected Finding:
Key Discoveries:
Critical Insight:
Problem Identified:
Corrected Approach:
Corrected SMILES:
Validation Steps:
Comparison Analysis:
TYMS Validation:
Methodology Improvement:
Future Applications:
Complex Engineering Challenge: TYMS-GFP represents a sophisticated fusion protein system requiring preservation of both enzymatic activity (thymidylate synthase function) and fluorescent properties (GFP chromophore maturation) while maintaining structural integrity for PFOA binding studies.
Multi-Parameter Requirements: Success required achieving simultaneously: • Protein purity exceeding 95% by SDS-PAGE analysis for accurate binding studies • Correct molecular weight confirmation (64 kDa) distinguishing intact fusion from truncation products • Preserved quaternary structure validation through analytical techniques (CD spectroscopy for secondary structure, AUC for oligomeric state) • Sufficient production yield (>1 mg per preparation) for comprehensive biophysical characterization • Maintained fluorescence activity enabling detection and quantification in biosensor applications
Technical Complexity: Fusion proteins present unique challenges including increased proteolytic susceptibility, potential folding interference between domains, and complex purification requirements necessitating multi-step protocols to achieve research-grade purity.
Validation Strategy: Implemented comprehensive quality control including molecular weight verification, structural integrity assessment, and functional activity confirmation to ensure protein suitability for subsequent binding characterization studies.
Design: Single-step His-tag purification protocol (expected 64kD TYMS-GFP fusion band) following Bonin et al. methods with University of Louisville Protein Expression and Purification Core guidance
Build: Express TYMS-GFP, perform His-tag purification
Test: SDS-PAGE → two bands observed: lower MW (37kD TYMS truncation/monomer or 27kD GFP-only) and higher MW (64kD TYMS-GFP fusion or 74kD TYMS dimers, though dimerization should be disrupted in denaturing PAGE)
Learn: One-step purification insufficient → add SEC step for single pure protein
Design: Add Size Exclusion Chromatography using HiLoad 16/600 Superdex 75 pg column (Cytiva, Marlborough, MA)
Build: Two-step purification: His-tag → SEC with fraction collection for six separate peaks
Test: SDS-PAGE + fluorescence check → Peak 3 contains pure TYMS-GFP (~64kD), Peak 4 contains ~30kDa protein with highest fluorescence (likely cleaved GFP), Peaks 1,2,5,6 insufficient protein
Learn: Two-step purification essential for intact TYMS-GFP; larger SEC column could improve separation and reduce fraction overlap
Confirm folding and oligomeric state via AUC and CD for molecular dynamics team validation; confirm proper fusion protein folding
Prepare purified protein for analysis
First run failed → buffer mismatch
Fixed by buffer exchange (H, Na, PO4)
Success after correction → pure, properly folded, correct size protein; observed monomer-dimer equilibrium between fusion proteins and PFOA (unable to test further due to instrument limitations with PFOA)
Critical Validation Requirement: Quantitative confirmation of TYMS-PFOA interaction represents the cornerstone validation for our entire biosensor concept. Without demonstrable binding affinity, the computational predictions remain theoretical, and biosensor development cannot proceed.
Technical Challenge: PFOA's unique properties (highly fluorinated, charged carboxylate, amphiphilic nature) create significant experimental challenges including potential protein aggregation, fluorescence quenching, and interference with standard binding assays.
Multi-Technique Strategy: Recognizing the potential for technique-specific artifacts, we implemented parallel validation using three orthogonal approaches: • Microscale Thermophoresis (MST): Direct binding measurement through thermophoretic mobility changes • UV-Visible Spectroscopy: Protein conformational changes upon ligand binding • Nuclear Magnetic Resonance (NMR): High-resolution structural interaction mapping
Success Criteria: Establish quantitative binding parameters (Kd, stoichiometry, cooperativity) suitable for biosensor design optimization, with cross-technique validation confirming result reproducibility and eliminating potential experimental artifacts.
Test if proteins bind to positive controls
Prepare control samples
Run MST with controls
Controls validated; proceed to titration
16-point serial dilution starting at 2 mM PFOA
Prepare samples and load into capillaries
Titration failed due to user error and aggregation
Need simplified protocol with aggregation prevention
Simplified protocol with wash and centrifugation steps to prevent aggregation
Repeat 4.1.2 with optimized sample preparation
Successful binding detection, no saturation observed
Protocol works; need lower starting concentration
Binding check with optimized conditions
Run experiment with validated protocol
Worked but results worse than 4.1.1; possible buffer issue
Buffer optimization needed; proceed to kinetic activity assessment
Test 4.1.3 protocol with UV/Vis detection
Run parallel UV/Vis experiment
UV/Vis failed; same results as MST
Consistent results across methods; MST validated
Follow published paper protocol with formaldehyde treatment
Prepare samples according to literature
Results suspicious; modified approach failed
Literature protocol not suitable for our system
Retry without formaldehyde treatment
Simplified sample preparation
No improvement in results
UV/Vis may not be optimal detection method
Test different wavelengths for detection
Scan multiple wavelengths
No significant improvement at any wavelength
UV/Vis not suitable; confirm MST as primary method
Attempt NMR for better data quality than UV/Vis
Prepare samples for NMR analysis
Poor buffer conditions prevented proper analysis
Time constraints prevented optimization; MST remains primary method
Lower start concentration (500 µM PFOA) based on learnings
Prepare optimized dilution series
Clean sigmoidal binding curve obtained
Kd = 217 µM → validated binding affinity for TYMS-PFOA interaction
Strategic Innovation: While our protein-based approach provides immediate PFOA detection capability, the ultimate goal requires developing genetic circuits where PFOA exposure directly activates gene expression, eliminating the need for separate protein production and purification steps.
Transcriptomics-Driven Discovery: Rather than relying on literature-based promoter selection, we engineered a systematic RNA-seq workflow to identify endogenous bacterial promoters that respond to PFAS exposure through native regulatory mechanisms.
Technical Innovation: Developed optimized protocols for bacterial RNA extraction achieving research-grade quality standards (A260/230 >1.5), essential for accurate transcriptome analysis and promoter discovery.
Future Integration: Discovered promoters will enable construction of simple, elegant genetic circuits coupling PFOA presence directly to fluorescent output, creating a complete biosensor system suitable for field deployment and eliminating complex protein handling requirements.
Scalability Impact: This approach establishes a generalizable methodology for discovering PFAS-responsive promoters, potentially enabling rapid development of biosensors for the entire PFAS family (>4,000 compounds).
Design: RNA extraction from E. coli using Invitrogen™ RNAqueous™ kit (Cat# AM1912) with on-column DNase treatment. Target purity: A260/230 = 2.0–2.2
Build: Extract RNA from 4 bacterial samples following manufacturer's protocol
Test: Measure purity using NanoDrop spectrophotometer
Results:
| Sample | Conc (ng/μl) | A260/280 | A260/230 |
|---|---|---|---|
| A | 74.8 | 2.05 | 0.21 |
| B | 79.6 | 2.02 | 0.17 |
| C | 113.5 | 2.04 | 0.67 |
| D | 164.8 | 2.07 | 0.87 |
Learn: Poor A260/230 ratio (avg 0.48) due to chaotropic salt contamination from wash buffer
Design: Add extra centrifugation step (15,000 x g, 1 min, open caps) before elution to remove trapped wash buffer
Build: Implement modified protocol with additional centrifugation
Test: Extract RNA from 24 samples with optimized protocol
Results: Significant improvement in both purity and concentration:
Learn: Protocol validated for RNA-seq library preparation; extra centrifugation step essential for quality
| Sample # | Conc (ng/μl) | A260/280 | A260/230 | Quality |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 277.7 | 2.14 | 2.00 | High |
| 2 | 266.8 | 2.13 | 1.65 | Good |
| 3 | 233.5 | 2.04 | 0.35* | Poor |
| 4 | 217.2 | 2.12 | 2.24 | High |
| 5 | 216.0 | 2.13 | 1.73 | Good |
| 17 | 385.6 | 2.13 | 2.04 | High |
| 20 | 310.2 | 2.11 | 2.25 | High |
| 21 | 280.3 | 2.11 | 2.10 | High |
| 22 | 231.8 | 2.11 | 2.01 | High |
*Samples marked with asterisk have poor A260/230 ratios
Quality control sequencing using cost-effective MiSeq Nano flow cell before full sequencing run
Expected: ~4.17% reads per sample (24 samples total)
Pool RNA-seq libraries and load onto MiSeq Nano flow cell (Cat# MS-103-1001)
Setup: Single-end 1x100bp sequencing
Sequence libraries and analyze read distribution across samples
Issues found: Uneven read distribution
Sample #11 overrepresented (17.8% vs 4.17% target)
Samples #18 and #24 insufficient data
Adjust volumes for next cycle
Issues Identified:
Optimization for Next Cycle:
Future Work: Full transcriptomics analysis to identify PFOA-responsive promoters for next-generation biosensor circuits
Design: Help peers and younger students gain exposure to basic biology fundamentals. Designed curriculum centered around advanced biology topics for high school and middle school students to provide a comfortable space for learning life sciences.
Build: Developed curriculum following Khan Academy and Study.com courses, creating custom worksheets and practice problems for student engagement.
Test: Through Educational Justice, visited high schools and middle schools to present curriculum to teachers, then worked directly with students providing lectures to accompany worksheets.
Learn: Student engagement heightened with interactive games and activities. Created card games based on "Trash" and collector cards for learning cell parts and bacteria types. Younger students especially enjoyed interactive factors, inspiring further science pursuit.
Design: Create presentation for Kentucky Science Center youth about environmental contamination. Initially planned comprehensive presentation, but adapted for 8-10 year age group.
Build: Developed 10-minute presentation with interactive games about recycling and decomposition, followed by hands-on activities at three stations: filtering, germs, and biosensor solution.
Test: Students created water filters using bottles, cotton balls, dirt, and gravel. Used GloGerm to simulate real germs and demonstrate transmission. Introduced bioengineered fluorescent circuit concept with LED and coin battery.
Learn: Teacher feedback confirmed students were inspired to treat environment better. Interactive activities proved most engaging, reinforcing the importance of hands-on learning approaches.
Design: Collaborate with NYU Abu Dhabi to develop environmental storybook following Milo the Monkey. Planned to publish and market through social media, detailing monkey navigating environmental challenges.
Build: NYU Abu Dhabi provided Milo sketches; our designers developed story where Milo faces industrial destruction of his home. Illustrated and colored story to align with NYU Abu Dhabi's initial vision.
Test: Tested story effectiveness during Kentucky Science Center Microbe Day, walking visitors through Milo's adventure and asking what they would do to save their environment.
Learn: Simple story had more impact than multiple presentations. Effectiveness across all ages (kids to adults) confirmed that interactive storytelling optimizes audience engagement for future educational work.
Iteration 1: Basic curriculum development
Iteration 2: Game-based learning integration
Station 1 - Filtering Activity:
Station 2 - Germ Simulation:
Station 3 - Biosensor Demo:
Immediate Goals (Next 6 months):
Long-term Vision (1-2 years):