Bio-computing is a promising field with potential applications in bio-security, environmental
monitoring,
and personalized medicine[1]. However, there has always been a
significant gap between successfully
constructing logic gates and actually achieving computation. Previous designs were always limited to
within a single cell, constrained by available orthogonal components and cellular metabolic
pressures,
making it difficult to construct complex adders[2].
To solve this problem, we develop a novel approach to constructing a biocomputer—utilizing quorum
sensing
and spatial diffusion to form logic gates[3] and build a complex
adder. We also establish three orthogonal
quorum sensing systems to solve the crosstalk issue between different colonies. At the same time, we
design
a light-controlled AHL degradation enzyme based on AiiA[5] and a
light-inducible protein degradation
tag, enabling
the restart and re-computation of the entire system.
1. Orthogonal Quorum Sensing Systems with Biosensors
Our biological computer is built on quorum-sensing (QS) systems to construct
logic gates. The signaling input is the quorum-sensing molecule N-acyl homoserine lactones (AHL).
Receptor proteins receive inputs and become active, and drive transcription from the
cognate promoter. To prevent crosstalk between different computational modules, we selected
orthogonal QS systems as the logic gate signaling system; this also allows future users to assemble
complex circuits from our gates without interference.
Among these, the Rhl and Las systems are orthogonal to each other, while Rhl, Tra, and Cin are
mutually orthogonal in all pairwise combinations[4] (Figure 1).
Figure 1. (A) Heatmap characterization of the
overlap observed when QS
signalling systems are induced with non-cognate ligands, referred to as signal crosstalk. The
heatmap was constructed using the highest (1E−4 M) concentration of ligands. Solid black lines mark
the AHL signalling systems. Dashed black lines (zoom-in) show the selection of QS signalling systems
which are signal orthogonal. Signal orthogonal systems are defined as non-cognate signal recognition
and activation remaining under 33 % of maximum, when compared with cognate ligand. The data
represent average values of 3 biological replicates. (B) Schematic representation
of the experimental
method used to characterize signal crosstalk between the QS signalling systems. The binding of QS
receptors to its cognate promoter in the presence of non-cognate ligands is referred to as signal
crosstalk[4].
In subsequent logic-gate construction, we detect quantitative mapping of AHL distributions after
diffusion on solid
media
and the expression strengths of the four orthogonal QS systems. Accordingly, we construct biosensor
bacteria
for each system (Figure 2). Taking the Rhl system as an example: a constitutive promoter (PJ23106)
drives expression of
the
cognate transcriptional regulator RhlR; upon binding its ligand
C₄-AHL, the RhlR-AHL complex
activates the Prhl promoter,
initiating expression of the fluorescent protein sfGFP (Figure. 2A). Fluorescence output is
proportional to local AHL concentration,
enabling quantification of the signal. To generate spatial concentration profiles, a defined volume
of AHL solution is dispensed
onto one locus of an agar plate, and a biosensor colony is inoculated at a second locus (Figure 2B).
AHL diffuses radially through
the medium; the resulting fluorescence intensity at the biosensor site reports the concentration at
that coordinate. Employing this
assay, we build AHL biosensors and determine their diffusion-response curves (Figure 2C).
Figure 2. Characterization of AHL biosensor
bacteria. (A) Genetic
circuits of biosensors for four orthogonal QS systems. (B) Schematic
representation of the
experimental method used to quantify the AHL signal by fluorescence of biosensors on solid
media. (C) By fluorescence photography and photo data processing, we can get
the relationship
between the diffusion distance, AHL concentration and downstream gene expression intensity.
2. Calculating: Logic Gates and Addition Calculator
a) Using High-pass and Bandpass Bacteria to Build
Logic Gates
The fundamental logic gates include AND, OR, and XOR gates; their corresponding truth tables are as
follows:
Figure 3. Truth tables for AND, OR, and XOR logic
gates.
If we use high and low expression levels as binary outputs 1 and 0, the corresponding
concentration-response curves are:
Figure 4. Corresponding concentration-response
curves of OR, AND and
XOR gates
The curves above can be summarized as two basic types: high-pass curve, in which cells switch ON
above
a threshold concentration, and bandpass curve, in which cells are ON only within an intermediate
concentration. Both response behaviors can be implemented within a single bacterial strain using
simple circuits. Differences in activation thresholds—e.g., both AND and OR gates exhibit high-pass
behavior, but OR responds at moderate concentrations while AND does not—can be tuned simply by
adjusting the distance between the signal input site and the biosensor colony.
In the high-pass strain (Figure 5A), the circuit is constructed as follows (RhlR-CinI example).
A constitutive PJ23106 promoter drives expression of the transcriptional regulator RhlR. Upon
binding C₄-AHL,
the RhlR-AHL complex activates the Prhl promoter, inducing expression of the synthase CinI, which
produces 3-OH-C₁₄:₁ AHL
as the output signal. At low input levels of C₄-AHL, no 3-OH-C₁₄:₁ AHL is generated; above a
threshold concentration, the
output appears, yielding a high-pass response.
Figure 5 (A). The genetic circuit of
RhlR-CinI high-pass
bacteria
Input Signal : C₄AHL
High-pass : input > 1 -- AND
Output signal : 3OHC₁₄:₁ AHL
Figure 5 (B). The genetic circuit of
RhlR-TraI bandpass
bacteria
Input Signal : C₄AHL
Bandpass : 0 < input < 2 -- XOR
Output signal : 3OC₈AHL
In the bandpass strain (Figure 5B), the circuit is constructed as follows (RhlR-TraI-bandpass
example). A
constitutive PJ23106 promoter drives expression of the transcriptional regulator RhlR. Upon binding
C₄-AHL, the RhlR-AHL complex activates the Prhl promoter, which drives expression of T7 RNA
polymerase (T7 RNAP) and the repressor PhlF; together, these components jointly modulate expression
of the downstream synthase TraI and the resulting output of 3OC₈-AHL.
The bandpass behavior is produced by a T7 promoter that is repressed by the PhlF transcription
factor[3]. T7 RNAP and PhlF are expressed from Prhl promoter,
respectively. In the absence of C4-AHL,
no T7 RNAP is expressed, and the output promoter is not activated. At intermediate levels of C4-AHL,
T7 RNAP is produced, and TraI transcription from the output promoter occurs. At high C4-AHL levels,
PhlF is expressed at a high enough concentration to inhibit TraI transcription from the output
promoter.
Figure 6. Using high-pass and bandpass bacteria
to build OR, AND
and XOR logic gates. (A) The genetic circuit of high-pass and bandpass bacteria
of the single-gate
verification phase. (B) Schematic representation of the experimental method
used to find the best
bacteria position for each kind of logic gates on solid media. (C) Logic gates:
OR, AND, XOR.
Notably, during the single-gate verification phase, both high-pass and bandpass bacteria are
engineered to
express green fluorescent protein rather than downstream AHL synthases (Figure 7A). After validating
the high-pass
and band-pass circuits, we map their diffusion profiles on agar (Figure 7B). Feeding these profiles
into our
computational framework yields the optimal spatial coordinates for inputs and outputs, enabling the
assembly of
arbitrary logic gates (Figure 7C).
Figure 7. Using high-pass and bandpass bacteria
to build OR, AND and XOR logic gates.
(A) The genetic circuit of high-pass and bandpass bacteria of the single-gate
verification phase. (B)
Schematic representation of the experimental method used to find the best bacteria position for
each kind of logic
gates on solid media. (C) The calculation results of three kinds of logic gates
utilizing spatial
diffusion.
b) Addition Calculators: Half-adder and
Full-adder
With single-gate modules validated, we next combine them to build half- and full-adders capable of
binary addition.
The half-adder is the minimal arithmetic unit, summing two 1-bit inputs without carry-in (Figure 8A).
Its designation as “half” reflects that it omits any carry propagated from a preceding stage.
The full-adder overcomes this limitation by accepting three 1-bit inputs—two addends plus the
carry-in—thereby enabling complete multi-bit addition (Figure 8B). Together, these adders constitute
the foundational blocks of the arithmetic logic unit (ALU) in digital architectures.
Figure 8. The schematic diagram of digital logic
circuits, truth tables and the genetic circuits. (A) The half-adder.
(B) The full-adder.
Inspection of the truth table reveals that the requisite adder functions can be realised by combining
distinct high-pass and band-pass colonies.
For the half-adder, the carry-out C₁ behaves as an AND gate and is implemented with a single
high-pass colony, whereas the sum bit S₁ behaves as an XOR gate and is realised with a band-pass
colony (Figure 8A).
For the full-adder, the carry-out C₁ is again an AND gate and is encoded by a high-pass colony;
the sum bit Sᵢ requires a combination of high-pass and band-pass colonies to yield the correct
composite response (Figure 8B).
c) Serial Calculation
A single full-adder handles only a 1-bit summation. To process multi-bit binary numbers we chain
multiple
adders in series. Each stage employs a distinct orthogonal QS system so that the output AHL of one
adder becomes the diffusible input of the next. By adjusting the distance between adders and the
spotting timing, we achieve serial computation; the accompanying animation depicts one complete
calculation (Click the plate below to see).
DA
+ CB
-----
αβγ
Input Points
A Input
B Input
C Input
D Input
Processors
Half Adder
Amplifier
Full Adder
Output Points
α Output
β Output
γ Output
3. Refreshing: Light-Induced Degradation Modules
a) Optogenetic AHL degradation
enzyme AiiA
To achieve repeatable computation, we need to design a degradation enzyme capable of real-time
response to blue light
signals and rapid degradation of quorum sensing molecules. AiiA is an enzyme that can inactivate the
acylhomoserine
lactone quorum-sensing signal[5]. We split AiiA into N-terminal (n
AiiA) and C-terminal
(c AiiA) fragments,, with VVD domain attached to the internal end of each fragment , whereby blue
light irradiation
induces VVD dimerization[6], facilitating the reassembly of the two
AiiA fragments into
a functional protein. (Figure 9) This design ensures that the two enzyme fragments do not
spontaneously assemble into an
active enzyme in the absence of blue light. However, under blue light illumination, the interaction
between the LOV
domains facilitates the assembly of the two fragments into a complete enzyme [7],
thereby reconstituting its degradation activity.
Figure 9. The design of light-inducible QS molecule
degradation enzyme.
The challenge in this design lies in identifying optimal truncation sites. These sites must allow for
the normal fusion of the two LOV domains, ensuring the reassembled
enzyme exhibits full catalytic activity under blue light. Most critically, they also prevent
spontaneous
assembly of the fragments in the dark. Fortunately, through comprehensive literature research, we
identified the online,
web-based protein design tool SPELL to address this key issue.
SPELL is an acronym for Split Protein
Reassembly by Ligands or Light.
SPELL server predicts potential split sites in proteins such that two halves of a
split protein are attached to a couple of other proteins (that dimerize upon ligand or light
stimulation) can reassemble into a full protein upon ligand or light stimulation. The server ranges
potential split sites according to the degree of prediction reliability.[8]
Using SPELL, we select three truncation sites for the AiiA degradation enzyme: between residues
154-155, 181-182, and
208-209 (Figure 10). These truncation variants are subsequently validated through molecular dynamics
simulations and
protein structure analysis tools, including AlphaFold and Gromacs. We also analyze the enzymatic
activity of AiiA
truncation variants by plotting degradation curves.
Figure 10. The genetic circuits of three kinds of
light-inducible split AiiA enezymes.
b) Light-induced Protein Degradation Tag
To achieve the effect of repeatable operations, we design not only the AHL degradation
module but also a light-inducible degradation module for the result display protein,
enabling a refreshing for the result presentation.
We choose the modular light-inducible degradation tag LOVdeg. It is based on an LOV2 domain
of Avena sativa phototropin 1 (AsLOV2). The mechanism is that the C-terminal Jα helix
becomes unstructured
upon blue light absorption, which could be utilized to provide light-inducible protein degradation.
In the dark, the C-terminal "E-A-A" motif is structurally caged within the folded Jα helix,
stabilizing the domain. Upon blue light illumination, the Jα helix unfolds, exposing "E-A-A"
as an unstructured degron, which targets the protein for degradation by the host
proteasome.[9]
Figure 11. The mechanism of light-inducible
degradation tag LOVdeg (utilizing AsLOV2).[9]
We fuse the light-inducible degradation tag, LOVdeg, to the C-terminus of the fluorescence protein.
When exposed to blue light, the LOVdeg tag induces the degradation of the fluorescent protein,
refreshing the result display. (Figure 11, 12)
Furthermore, we can also fuse the LOVdeg tag with AHL synthases such as RhlI and LasI, potentially
enabling comprehensive refresh operations. (Figure 12)
Figure 12. The genetic circuit of functionally
resettable high-pass bacteria and result display bacteria.
4. LOGIC Toolkit
To enable future teams to use our work, WHU-China plans to establish a LOGIC toolkit, aiming to
contribute to the advancement of synthetic biology.
a) Wet Lab
i. Orthogonal AHL Systems with Standardized Biosensors
Figure 13. Orthogonal AHL systems and
biosensors.
We validated several orthogonal AHL systems, built standardized biosensors, and mapped their
diffusion-response curves. These ready-to-use sensors let anyone measure AHL concentrations and
facilitate spatial biocomputation with engineered bacteria.
ii. Several Logic Gate Modules
Figure 14. Logic gate modules utilizing QS
systems and spatial diffusion
We designed and experimentally verified multiple logic gate modules, enabling modular
circuitassembly.
iii. Light-induced Degradation System
Figure 15. Light-inducible AHL-lactonase design
By inserting the VVD photosensor domain, we engineered a light-inducible AHL-lactonase (AiiA)
that enables to refresh the biological computer, which can also expand optogenetic control over
quorum-sensing systems for broader synthetic-biology applications.
b) Dry Lab
i. Modeling Method of Spatial Computation
We use Fick's law to calculate the diffusion of AHL molecules.
Biocomputers utilize biological molecules (e.g., DNA, RNA, proteins, or living cells) instead of
silicon-based materials to perform computational tasks, employing genetic circuits and
biological
logic gates for information processing. Their core advantages include ultra-low energy
consumption
(ideal for implantable medical devices), high parallelism (DNA computing processes massive data
simultaneously), and biocompatibility (enabling direct integration into biological systems).
In addition to performing binary computation, LOGIC can also be applied to detect target
substances
in the environment. It directly displays both the types and quantities of target substances
present,
providing more intuitive detection results. In addition, if our project is further developed,
such as combining with microfluidic technology, there is hope for its application in the
diagnosis of diseases through biomolecular detection.
b) Education
LOGIC can also become an ideal educational tool, where users could input two binary numbers to obtain
an answer to the addition calculation, allowing children to simultaneously experience binary
computing and synthetic biology, and combining education with entertainment. Furthermore, with deep
integration of advanced microfluidic technology, our project can achieve further refinement in the
future.
Our project achieves the construction of a complex adder by combining multiple bacteria, thereby
eliminating the need for further genetic editing of the bacteria. It constructs a lightweight and
flexible adjustable computing system, providing a new method for biological computing and opening up
new development directions. In the future, through precise control methods such as microfluidics, we
can truly realize fully automatic biological computing chips at the sub-micron level and apply them
to real-world scenarios.
References
Grozinger, L., Amos, M., Gorochowski, T. E., Carbonell, P., Oyarzún, D. A., Stoof, R., Fellermann, H.,
Zuliani, P., Tas, H., & Goñi-Moreno, A. (2019). Pathways to cellular supremacy in biocomputing.
Nature Communications, 10(1). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-019-13232-z
Bonnerjee, D., Mukhopadhyay, S., & Bagh, S. (2019). Design, Fabrication, and Device Chemistry of a
3-Input-3-Output Synthetic Genetic Combinatorial Logic Circuit with a 3-Input AND Gate in a Single
Bacterial Cell. Bioconjugate Chemistry, 30(12), 3013–3020. https://doi.org/10.1021/acs.bioconjchem.9b00517
Fedorec, A. J. H., Treloar, N. J., Wen, K. Y., Dekker, L., Ong, Q. H., Jurkeviciute, G., Lyu, E.,
Rutter, J. W., Zhang, K. J. Y., Rosa, L., Zaikin, A., & Barnes, C. P. (2024). Emergent digital
bio-computation through spatial diffusion and engineered bacteria. Nature Communications,
15(1). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-024-49264-3
Jonkergouw, C., Savola, P., Osmekhina, E., Van Strien, J., Batys, P., & Linder, M. B. (2023).
Exploration of chemical diversity in intercellular quorum sensing signalling systems in prokaryotes.
Angewandte Chemie International Edition, 63(2). https://doi.org/10.1002/anie.202314469
Zoltowski, B. D., Vaccaro, B., & Crane, B. R. (2009). Mechanism-based tuning of a LOV domain
photoreceptor. Nature Chemical Biology, 5(11), 827–834. https://doi.org/10.1038/nchembio.210
Han, T., Chen, Q., & Liu, H. (2016). Engineered photoactivatable genetic switches based on the bacterium
phage T7 RNA polymerase. ACS Synthetic Biology, 6(2), 357–366. https://doi.org/10.1021/acssynbio.6b00248
Dagliyan, O., Krokhotin, A., Ozkan-Dagliyan, I., Deiters, A., Der, C. J., Hahn, K. M., & Dokholyan, N.
V. (2018). Computational design of chemogenetic and optogenetic split proteins. Nature
Communications, 9(1). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-018-06531-4
Tague, N., Coriano-Ortiz, C., Sheets, M. B., & Dunlop, M. J. (2023). Light-inducible protein degradation
in E. coli with the LOVdeg tag. eLife, 12. https://doi.org/10.7554/elife.87303
This page doesn't work properly in this screen size, you might encounter major bugs that affect your
reading experience. Please try visiting us using a larger screen.