Biosensors and high-pass bacteria
Cycle 1 Ensure the feasibility of diffusion experiments
Design
In order to ensure the feasibility of our AHL diffusion experiments, we used the plasmids LasR-deGFP and LuxR-deGFP from 2024 WHU_China to construct high-pass engineered bacteria with fluorescence induced by 3-oxo-C12 HSL and 3-oxo-C6 HSL.
In this cycle, the expression of the downstream corresponding AHL receptor proteins (LuxR and LasR) are activated by the T7 promoter and lac operator. The lac operator ensures that LuxR and LasR are only expressed when needed, thereby reducing the metabolic burden on the engineered bacteria. The deGFP protein is induced by the promoters Plux and Plas. (Figure 1-1) When adding different concentrations of AHL, the bacteria will express different level of GFP.
Build
We transformed the plasmids LasR-deGFP and LuxR-deGFP from 2024 WHU_China into E. coli BL21 (DE3) strain. (Figure 1-2)
Test
To verify the response of E. coli to the two AHL molecules, 3-oxo-C12 HSL and 3-oxo-C6 HSL, we implemented liquid induction and solid diffusion experiments.
In liquid induction experiments, we mixed IPTG-induced bacterial cultures with serially diluted AHLs in 96-well plates. OD600 and fluorescence intensity were measured using a microplate reader once an hour (Figure 1-3).
Through liquid culture and fluorescence detection, we observed that in the first 2 hours, the biosensors could detect different concentrations of AHL. However, as time went on, the bacterial proliferation became excessive, and the detection effect declined (Figure 1-3).
In agar plate colony experiments, we dispensed the culture and different concentration 3-oxo-C12-HSL at the positions shown in Figure 1-4A. After 12h incubation, we detected the fluorescence of the colonies with inverted fluorescent microscope (Figure 1-4).
Learn
Biosensor of 3-oxo-C6 HSL does not show a good decline curve, which may be due to the high concentration of AHL in the short diffusion distance, which disturbs the metabolism of engineered bacteria or inhibits the growth of colonies, while the fluorescence intensity in the far distance may be caused by leakage expression.
Cycle 2 Replace T7 promoter with constitutive promoter J23106
Design
To eliminate the induction step required before using the biosensor and to avoid the excessive expression caused by the T7 strong promoter, we replaced the T7 promoter and lac operator with the constitutive promoter PJ23106. (Figure. 1-5)
Build
We performed PCR and Gibson Assembly to build plasmid PJ23106-LasR-deGFP. (Figure 1-6)
Test
Sequencing confirmed transformation success.
Referencing the work of Fedorec et al. (2024), we employed agar plate colony experiment to validate the “highpass”. We dispensed the culture and different concentration 3-oxo-C12-HSL at the positions shown in the map (Figure 1-7A) onto the surface of the agar plate, detecting the fluorescence with inverted fluorescence microscope.
Other concrete details can be found on the experiments page.
Learn
In the agar plate colony experiment, colonies closer to the central point, which had access to higher concentrations of AHL, did not express more GFP. Instead, colonies slightly farther from the centre point exhibited the highest fluorescence. (Figure. 6A) Observing the colony morphology revealed that the colonies located farther from the centre grew better. (Figure. 6B) We speculated that overmuch 3-oxo-C12 HSL may affect the colony growth and thereby influence the fluorescence intensity.
Cycle 3 Use medium-copy-number backbone
Design
We hypothesized that the primary reasons for poor bacterial growth may include two aspects: First, the constitutive expression of the receptor protein on the high-copy plasmid (ori is pColE1) significantly increases the metabolic burden on the engineering bacteria. Second, a high concentration of the AHL ligand strongly induces the promoter to drive excessive expression of GFP, further exacerbating metabolic stress. The combined effect of these two factors may lead to plasmid loss under sustained high metabolic load. To mitigate these issues, we propose the following strategy: replacing the ori with the medium-copy p15A origin and adopting the Rhl quorum sensing system that is orthogonal[3] to more systems than Las to construct a more stable biosensor bacteria. The following circuit is designed accordingly. (Figure.1-8)
Build
We obtained RhlR and PRhl fragments from Shi-shen Du's Lab. Using Gibson assembly, we inserted these fragments into the iGEM JUMP collection plasmid pJUMP26-1A (sfGFP) to construct the RhlR-sfGFP plasmid, which was then transformed into E. coli DH5α. (Figure 1-9, 1-10)
Test
We performed colony PCR and sequencing to verify successful plasmid construction. Sequencing confirmed transformation success. (Figure. 1-11)
We conducted the agar plate colony experiment on the engineered bacteria to determine whether they could emit green fluorescence, thereby achieving biosensor functionality, and plotted a series of dose response curves. (Figure. 1-12)
Learn
Through spiral dispensing in agar plate colony experiment, we confirmed that this design generated consistent biosensor response curves, demonstrating that the ability to detect C4-HSL concentrations in solid media. The obtained data display well-defined trends, making them suitable for subsequent fitting and computational mathematical modeling by the Model Group. Furthermore, Rhl biosensor bacteria carrying the RhlR-sfGFP plasmid exhibits a highpass filtering behavior, which supports their use as independent logic gate modules. The relevant verification can be viewed on the Results page.
Building upon this methodology, we subsequently succeeded in constructing the LasR-sfGFP plasmid and CinR-sfGFP plasmid, whose experimental result meet our expectation. However, we encountered difficulties during the construction of the TraR-sfGFP plasmid (corresponding to Cycle 4).
Build & test of LasR-sfGFP and CinR-sfGFP
Based on the successfully verified RhlR-sfGFP plasmid, we obtained the LasR and Plas fragments from the T7-LasR-deGFP plasmid using PCR. We then replaced the Rhl system in the RhlR-sfGFP plasmid and constructed the LasR-sfGFP plasmid using Gibson assembly. (Figure. 1-13A)
Concurrently, the CinR_AM and Pcin_AM sequences, derived from the iGEM Distribution Kit, were utilised to substitute the Rhl system in the RhlR-sfGFP plasmid. The CinR-sfGFP plasmid was then constructed through Gibson assembly. (Figure. 1-13B)
We conducted the agar plate colony experiment on the engineering bacteria to determine whether they could emit green fluorescence, thereby achieving biosensor functionality, and plotted a series of dose response curves. (Figure. 1-14A, Figure. 1-14B)
Cycle 4 Optimize Tra biosensor bacteria
Design
Based on the successfully validated RhlR-sfGFP plasmid construct, we utilized the RhlR-sfGFP plasmid as backbone and incorporated the synthesized sequences of TraR and Ptra from GenScript to construct the TraR-sfGFP plasmid, thereby establishing the biosensor bacteria for the Tra system. The following circuit was designed accordingly. (Figure. 1-15)
Build
To construct the TraR-sfGFP plasmid, we used Gibson assembly to replace the RhlR and Prhl parts in the RhlR-sfGFP plasmid backbone with the synthesised TraR and Ptra sequences. After that, we transformed it into E. coli DH5α. (Figure. 1-16, Figure. 1-17)
Test
We performed colony PCR and sequencing. The plasmid was successfully constructed. But in the subsequent agar plate colony experiment, we did not observe significant fluorescence.
Learn
Consult the extant literature on the subject found that, wild type Ptra promoter is nonfunctional in E. coli. To solve the problem of the Tra system's poor functionality, researchers optimized and modified the Ptra promoter and TraR protein sequences.[1] (Figure. 1-18)
Therefore, we referenced the literature and changed the promoter to Ptra* and performed point mutation to the TraR.
Re-design & Build
We synthesized Ptra* using DNA oligo annealing and constructed Ptra*-TraR-sfGFP plasmid based on TraR-sfGFP plasmid (Figure 1-19A). Simultaneously, we substituted the amino acid at position 192 of TraR with Trp using site-directed mutagenesis , constructing Ptra*-TraR(W)-sfGFP plasmid (Figure 1-19B).
Test
We performed colony PCR and sequencing. The plasmids were successfully constructed. However, in the ensuing agar plate colony experiments, no significant fluorescent signal was detected, and increasing the concentration of 3-oxo-C8-HSL did not yield any noticeable improvement.
Learn
Upon consulting the literature, we discovered that the overall fluorescence response of Tra system was lower than that of the Las one. [1] (Figure 1-20) Therefore, we hypothesize that enhancing GFP expression can be achieved by increasing the plasmid copy number or replacing with a stronger constitutive promoter.
Redesign & build
On one hand, we replaced PJ23106 in the Ptra*-TraR-sfGFP plasmid with PJ23119, a stronger constitutive promoter, to construct J23119-Ptra*-TraR-sfGFP plasmid. (Figure 1-21A) On the other hand, we replaced the medium-copy p15A origin with the high-copy ColE1 origin to construct Ptra*-TraR-ColE1-sfGFP plasmid. (Figure 1-21B)
Test
We performed colony PCR and sequencing. The plasmids were successfully constructed.
Subsequently, we conducted the agar plate colony experiment, and found that Tra biosensor bacteria with Ptra*-TraR-ColE1-sfGFP plasmid could successfully respond to 3-oxo-C₈-HSL, and emit green fluorescence. Construction of the Tra biosensor bacteria was successful. (Figure 1-22)
Learn
Following increasing the plasmid copy number, green fluorescence was observed from the Tra biosensor bacteria, indicating that the functionality of both TraR and the Ptra* part was successfully confirmed.
Band-pass engineered bacteria
Cycle 1 Conduct a proof-of-concept using the IPTG system
Design
Similar to the “high-pass” circuit, we refered to the work of Fedorec et al. (2024) [2] to design a “band-pass” genetic circuit. The character of a band-pass filter is that the downstream circuit cannot be activated at too high and too low input signals, only the appropriate concentration of signal molecules can activate downstream gene expression. Bacteria with a band-pass circuit can be used as an XOR gate in our project, and can be combined with the “high-pass” bacteria to form a half-adder or full-adder under the condition of three inputs.
Refer to the work of Fedorec et al. (2024) [2] , we designed a band-pass genetic circuit induced by IPTG and the final effect is presented by the expression of sfGFP. The expression of sfGFP is promoted by T7 RNA polymerase(T7 RNAP) and inhibited by PhlF at the same time, only when the expression of both is at an appropriate level can sfGFP be expressed. This requires the input of IPTG to be at an appropriate intermediate concentration. When the input IPTG concentration is too low, sfGFP cannot be effectively expressed due to the lack of T7 RNAP ; and when the concentration of IPTG is too high, the expression of GFP will be inhibited by PhlF.
In our final design, sfGFP will be replaced by enzymes that can produce other inducible molecules like N-acyl homoserine lactones (AHLs).
We have designed the following circuit (Figure 2-1) to achieve the effect in the literature. We constructed two plasmids and transformed them into BL21(DE3) to have all the components in our bacteria. To regulate the relative expression levels of different components, we used vectors with different copy numbers.
Build
Based on the vector pJUMP26-1A(sfGFP) and pJUMP27-1A(sfGFP), we conducted PCR to linearize vectors and inserted promoter sequences through overlapping ends. Then we conduct Gibson Assembly to construct the two plasmids. (Figure 2-2) We conduct co-transformation on BL21(DE3), which already has T7 RNAP gene initiated by lac UV5 promoter on its genome.
Test
To test the IPTG band-pass circuit, we used two different patterns to inoculate colonies and added a series of concentrations of IPTG solution as input.
We expected colonies closest to and farthest from the input point both display low fluorescence expression, and other colonies display high fluorescence expression. We used two different patterns to inoculate colonies and give a series of concentrations of IPTG as input (Figure 2-3). The spiral pattern is used to verify the character of band-pass bacteria, and the logic gate pattern is used to find an appropriate combination of input distance and concentration to make the colony work as an XOR gate.
The result was very consistent with expectation: The colonies closest and farther away from the input point hardly emit fluorescence, and the colonies in the middle distance emit obvious fluorescence (Figure 2-4).
Further, we found some groups already possessing the properties of XOR logic gates(fig.27).
Learn
The successful validation of the IPTG band-pass circuit demonstrates that our approach to building a band-pass circuit is feasible. We will imitate the construction method to build a quorum sensing band-pass circuit.
Cycle2: Las band-pass circuit
Design
We first tried to construct the Las band-pass circuit firstly (Figure 2-6). The operating principle of Las circuit is similar to that in IPTG circuit in Cycle 1: when the 3-oxo-C12 HSL concentration is too low, GFP cannot be effectively expressed due to the lack of T7 RNAP; when the concentration of 3-oxo-C12 HSL is too high, the expression of GFP will be inhibited by PhlF. Only when the expression of both is at an appropriate level can GFP be expressed.
Build
To build the full circuit, we construct two intermediate plasmids first. Based on the Las half adder 1 in high-pass circuit, iGEM distribution kit and plasmids from 2024 WHU-China, we conducted PCR to linearize vectors and get fragments, then we conduct Gibson Assembly to construct the two intermediate plasmids. After that, we conduct the whole Las band-pass plasmid also with PCR and Gibson Assembly (Figure 2-7).
Test
We successfully obtain the "band-pass" bacteria. Similar to "high-pass" engineered bacteria, we first performed simplified Agar plate colony experiments. (Figure 2-8) Unfortunately, in the Agar plate colony experiments, our "band-pass" bacteria did not show any fluorescence signal.
Learn
We encountered many difficulties during the construction process of Las band-pass circuit, especially the issue of fragment and plasmid loss. We considered the plasmid may be too large and there may be too many duplicated fragments. Due to the success of cycle1, next step was to try the construction of IPTG band-pass circuit to build Las band-pass circuit.
Cycle 3: Las band-pass circuit improvement
Design
Due to the difficulty of the construction of Las system, we decided to reduce the engineering difficulty by constructing a circuit without T7 RNAP. The new circuit uses Plas to initiate expression of sfGFP directly (Figure 2-9).
Build
To build the full circuit, we conducted overlap PCR to get fragments, then we conduct restriction cloning to construct the whole plasmid. (Figure 2-10).
Test
We successfully obtain the "band-pass" bacteria. Similar to IPTG band-pass band-pass circuit, we used two different patterns to inoculate colonies and give a series of concentrations of IPTG and 3-oxo-C12 HSL at the same time in different proportions as input(Figure 2-3). Unfortunately it still did not show any fluorescence signal.
Learn
The reason for the lack of fluorescence signal might be excessive expression of phlF. T7 RNAP is a strong factor in initiating downstream gene expression and it is necessary in our circuit. So next we planned to add T7 RNAP back into our band-pass circuit.
Cycle 4 Las band-pass circuit improvement based on IPTG band-pass circuit
Design
Based on the experience we have gained from the previous two cycles, we decided to to gradually replace each component with which in Las band-pass circuit based on the IPTG band-pass circuit in cycle 1. We replaced lacI with lasR and lac UV5 promoter with Plas.
Theoretically, when both 3-oxo-C12 HSL and IPTG are used for induction, the engineered bacteria will exhibit a band-pass effect.
Build
Based on the plasmid IPTG-band-pass-p15A and IPTG-band-pass-pSC101 in cycle 2-1, we conducted Las dual plasmid system. Through high fidelity PCR and Gibson Assembly, we get fragment needed and engineered plasmid IPTG-band-pass-p15A to plasmid Cm-p15A-LasR-PhlF. The final dual plasmid system is shown below (Figure 2-11).
Test
Similar to IPTG band-pass band-pass circuit, we used two different patterns to inoculate colonies and give a series of concentrations of IPTG and 3-oxo-C12 HSL the same time in different proportions as input(Figure 2-3). The result is very consistent with expectation: The colonies closest and farther away from the input point hardly emit fluorescence, and the colonies in the middle distance emit obvious fluorescence(Figure 2-12).
However, due to the limited number of experiment groups, we did not obtain particularly ideal results in logic gate test(Figure 2-13).
Learn
The most difficult point is how to adjust the ratio of IPTG and 3-oxo-C12 HSL to achieve band-pass effect. We originally planned to fully replace the system, but due to time constraints we did not implement it.
Although we did not obtain obvious XOR logic gate due to time limitations, the band-pass effect showed by Las-IPTG double-plasmid bacteria has already indicated that it is likely to be an appropriate concentration ratio of 3-oxo-C12 HSL and IPTG to make it a XOR gate.
Cycle 5 Rhl band-pass circuit
As our ultimate goal is to use AHL as the "wire", we have further designed Rhl band-pass circuit based on Rhl quorum sensing system.
Design
The circuit of Rhl band-pass circuit is very similar to which in IPTG band-pass circuit. We use RhlR as a receptor to receive C4-HSL signals and activate T7 RNAP expression, which can further promote the expression of sfGFP; and we use phlF as a repressor to inhibit the expression of sfGFP. Maintaining an appropriate ratio between phlF and T7 RNAP can create a band-pass effect(Figure 2-14).
Build
Based on the Rhl high-pass plasmid and iGEM distribution kit, we conducted PCR to linearize vectors and get fragments, then we conduct Gibson Assembly to construct Rhl band-pass plasmid (Figure 2-15).
Test
Similar to IPTG band-pass circuit, we used two different patterns to inoculate colonies and added a series of concentrations of C4-HSL as input.
We expect that colonies near the input point show lower fluorescence expression, however the results did not fully meet our expectation.
Learn
The implementation of XOR gate effect strongly depends on the mutual coordination of PhlF, T7 RNAP and their relative components. A slight imbalance in the effects of the two elements can lead to disappointing results. Additionally, we found that the fluorescence intensity of colonies in all experimental groups was relatively low, we think it is an issue with the C4-HSL response threshold. In the next cycle, we will make improvements to address these two issues.
Cycle 6 Rhl band-pass circuit improvement based on IPTG band-pass circuit
Design
For the two issues in the previous cycle, we have come up with a solution for each. For the weak overall fluorescence brightness, we found a Rhl promoter(Part:BBa C0071 - parts.igem.org) from Team Tokyo Tech 2016 whose promoter activity was stronger than that of wild type (previously used)(Figure 2-16).
At the same time, another group of us tried a different way to improve the Rhl band-pass circuit. We transformed two plasmids into BL21(DE3) strain just like what we did in IPTG band-pass circuit. Actually, we replaced one of the plasmids in IPTG band-pass circuit to gradually replace IPTG with C4-HSL (the left one in Figure 2-18).
Build
Based on the plasmid Rhl-band-pass in the previous cycle, we conduct PCR and changed the promoter sequences through overlapping ends. Both Prhl were replaced by Prhl(NM)(Figure 2-17).
For the dual plasmid: based on the vector pJUMP26-1A(sfGFP), we conducted PCR to linearize vectors and inserted sequences of Rhl band-pass circuit through overlapping ends. Then we conduct Gibson Assembly to construct the plasmid. Using this plasmid and plasmid IPTG-band-pass-pSC101 in cycle 2-1, we conduct co-transformation on BL21(DE3), which already has T7 RNAP gene initiated by lac UV5 promoter on its genome. The final dual plasmid system is shown below (Figure 2-18).
Test
Similar to IPTG band-pass circuit, we used two different patterns to inoculate colonies and added a series of concentrations of IPTG and C4-HSL the same time in different proportions as input(Figure 2-3).
The result is very consistent with expectation: The colonies closest and farther from the input point hardly emit fluorescence, and the colonies in the middle distance emit obvious fluorescence (Figure 2-19).
However, due to the limited number of experiment groups, we did not obtain particularly ideal results in logic gate test (Figure 2-20).
Learn
The most difficult point is how to adjust the ratio of IPTG and C4-HSL to achieve band-pass effect. We originally planned to fully replace the system, but due to time constraints we did not implement it.
Although we did not obtain obvious XOR logic gate activated by AHL due to time limitations, the band-pass effect showed by Rhl-IPTG double-plasmid bacteria has already indicated that it is likely to be an appropriate concentration ratio of C4-HSL and IPTG to make it a XOR gate.
Connector bacteria
Cycle 1 Use the same AHL for transmission (amplifier)
Design
As the signal of one bit may spread the previous digit to cause crosstalk, we use amplifying bacteria to pull two digit apart from each other. To construct an amplifying bacteria of Las signal, we designed the LasR-LasI plasmid using the T7-LasR-deGFP plasmid as the vector. The LasR gene is initiated by the T7 promoter and regulated by the lac operon, thus requiring IPTG to induce expression. The LasI gene is regulated by the las promoter. When the externally imported 3-oxo-C12AHL molecules bind to the LasR protein, they can activate the las promoter, express the LasI gene, and export the Las AHL molecules, thereby amplifying the Las signal, lengthening the distance a signal can transmit.(Figure 3-1)
Build
We obtained the LasR-vector and LasI fragments from LasR-deGFP and LuxR-LasI (from 2024 WHU-China) by PCR respectively, and then constructed the LasR-LasI plasmid through Gibson assembly.(Figure 3-2)
Test
Plasmids were transformed into E. coli BL21(DE3). Sequencing verified transformation success.(Figure 3-3)
We dispense samples as shown in Figure 3-4. to verify the function of amplifying bacteria. Biosensors can detect the Las AHL signal output from the amplifying bacteria through green fluorescence. The position of eight biosensors are arranged carefully to avoid having the front block the back. Figure 3-5 shows the result.
Learn
We found that amplifying bacteria can achieve the amplification effect of receiving input 3-oxo-C12 HSL signals and output 3-oxo-C12 HSL signals. However, in the absence of 3-oxo-C12 HSL input, downstream biosensor could still detect 3-oxo-C12 HSL signal and produce green fluorescence due to amplification by the amplifying bacteria.
These abnormal phenomena indicate that the amplifying bacteria have certain leakage expression problems, that is, they generate 3-oxo-C12 HSL output signals when there is no external 3-oxo-C12 HSL input.We speculate that positive feedback effect of amplifying bacteria and leaky expression of the T7 promoter result in the expression of the LasI gene in the absence of 3-oxo-C12 HSL. On the other hand,the positive feedback between lasR and lasI may also play a role. To further prevent the leakage, we change amplifier to connector bacteria in later experiment, which can receive one AHL and turn this signal to another.
Cycle 2 Use different AHL for transmission to avoid excessive positive feedback (connector)
Design
In serial computation, the carry signal generated from a lower-bit operation must propagate to the next higher-bit position to perform multi-bit computations. We designed the connector bacteria to transfer the carry output (Ci).
The carry output (Ci) phenotype in half-adder and full-adder bacteria can be enable by the highpass genetic circuits, which form the basis of our connector bacteria. Within the same connector bacterium, the two QS systems employed are mutually orthogonal[3] to prevent crosstalk between the upstream and downstream colonies. (Figure 3-6)
Build
In this build, we employed mutually orthogonal QS system, Rhl and Las systems, and each built upon the plasmid of its own respective biosensor bacteria.
For instance, Gibson assembly was employed to replace the sfGFP gene in the LasR-sfGFP plasmid from the Las biosensor bacteria with the RhlI sequence (Figure 3-7A), which has the capacity to produce C4-HSL. This allowed us to create the LasR-RhlI connector bacteria (Figure 3-7B), which transmit signals to downstream colonies. Similarly, we constructed the RhlR-LasI connector bacteria (Figure 3-6C) using the RhlR-sfGFP plasmid as the backbone.
Test
We performed colony PCR and sequencing. The plasmids were successfully constructed.
Subsequently, we conducted a agar plate colony experiment and found that the AHL ligand concentration expressed by connector bacteria followed the diffusion curve, but there was certain leaky expressions.(Figure 3-8)
Learn
The AHL ligands produced by the connector bacteria were detected by the biosensor bacteria, which emitted fluorescence in accordance with a diffusion curve. The functional validation of the connector bacteria was successful in the test.
Cycle 3 Build connectors for different AHL systems
Design
Similarly, we utilize three pairwise orthogonal QS systems[3]—Rhl, Tra, and Cin system—to construct a greater variety of connector bacteria which is capable of transmitting QS signals from different molecules. (Figure 3-9)
Build
We utilized Gibson Assembly to replace the sfGFP gene in the RhlR-sfGFP plasmid from the Rhl biosensor bacteria with TraI and CinI sequences, thereby constructing RhlR-TraI and RhlR-CinI connector bacteria. (Figure 3-10)
Test
We performed colony PCR and sequencing. The plasmids were successfully constructed.
However, in the ensuing agar plate colony experiments, no significant fluorescent signal emitted by downstream biosensor bacteria was detected.
Learn
The functional validation of the two constructed connectors bacteria was unsuccessful. This may be because the inducer proteins express an insufficient concentration of AHL ligands, or because the function of the heterologous proteins is impaired in the E. coli chassis. Further investigation is required.